No items found.
Blog
November 14, 2025

How to overcome the top major incident management challenges in your organization

When a major IT incident hits, chaos ensues. Operations grind to a halt, and the pressure is on to fix things fast. The person at the center of this is the major incident manager. Their job is to be the calm in the chaos, guiding everyone to get services back up and running. 

But the road to recovery is anything but smooth. From dealing with confusing communication to managing the intense stress of a crisis, the problems incident managers face are relentless. Getting through these challenges takes more than just a skilled leader; it requires a smart game plan and the right tools. If you want to strengthen your incident response, you first need to understand the obstacles. 

This post dives into the biggest challenges in major incident management and lays out real solutions, including how major incident management automation can completely change the game.

What are the core roles and responsibilities of a major incident manager?

The role of a major incident manager is one of the most demanding in IT. Their primary responsibility is to take command of the incident response, acting as the single source of authority and communication. This involves more than just technical knowledge; it requires exceptional leadership, communication, and decision-making skills under pressure.

Key major incident manager responsibilities include:

  • Incident command: Immediately taking control of the major incident, establishing structure, and directing the response teams.
  • Coordination: Bringing together disparate teams, from technical SMEs to business stakeholders, to work cohesively towards a resolution.
  • Communication: Providing clear, concise, and timely updates to all stakeholders, including executive leadership, on the status of the incident and the expected time to recovery.
  • Escalation: Knowing when and how to escalate issues to senior management or other teams to get the necessary resources or decisions.
  • Documentation: Ensuring that all actions, decisions, and communications are logged for post-incident review and auditing purposes.

The major incident manager is ultimately accountable for the efficient and effective resolution of the incident, making their role pivotal in minimizing business impact.

What are the most common incident management issues and their consequences?

Even with a skilled manager at the helm, several potential incident management issues can derail the response effort. These problems often stem from systemic weaknesses in an organization's processes and technology.

  • Communication breakdowns: When teams can't communicate effectively, information gets lost, and actions are duplicated or missed entirely. This leads to confusion and delays.
  • Lack of real-time visibility: Without a central view of all response tasks, teams work in silos, unaware of what others are doing. This lack of visibility makes it impossible for the major incident manager to make informed decisions.
  • Siloed teams: Technical teams often work with their own tools and processes, creating friction when collaboration is needed during a crisis. This can slow down diagnosis and resolution.
  • Unclear escalation paths: If responders don't know who to escalate to or when, critical decisions can be delayed, leaving the incident to fester and cause more damage.

What daily problems do major incident managers face?

Beyond the systemic issues, major incident managers are constantly challenged by the logistics of mobilization and maintaining visibility. Finding the right technical resource often takes too long, and status updates become fragmented and lost across multiple chat sessions. This lack of incident visibility means responders can easily lose sight of critical actions, leading to lost effort and duplication.

A second major hurdle is the issue of unclear authority. Without formally defined power, the major incident manager can struggle to effectively direct senior technical staff or make rapid, critical decisions under pressure. This challenge is amplified by the difficult task of managing stakeholders with conflicting priorities. For example, business leaders demand immediate service restoration, while technical teams prioritize identifying the root cause to prevent recurrence.

What is the business impact of a poor critical incident response? 

When incident management is not executed well, the consequences can be severe. The most immediate impact is extended downtime, which directly translates to lost revenue and productivity. For every minute that a critical service is unavailable, the financial losses mount.

Beyond the immediate financial hit, poor incident response can lead to significant reputational damage. Typically, the news of an outage spreads quickly, eroding customer trust and loyalty. Breaching Service Level Agreements (SLAs) can also result in financial penalties and damaged client relationships. Ultimately, a failure to manage incidents effectively can have long-lasting negative effects on a company's bottom line and market position. This is why many organizations are now evaluating the benefits of choosing a major incident management system.

How can you overcome major incident management challenges?

The good news is that major incident management challenges are not insurmountable. Organizations can take several steps to empower their major incident managers and improve their response capabilities.

  • Establish clear authority: Formally define the major incident manager's role and give them the authority to make decisions and direct resources during an incident.
  • Standardize processes: Develop and document standard operating procedures for incident response so that everyone knows their role and what to do.
  • Invest in training: Regularly train your incident response teams, including your disaster recovery team roles and responsibilities, to ensure they are prepared for a real event.
  • Foster a culture of collaboration: Break down silos by encouraging cross-team collaboration and communication, both during and outside of incidents.

What tools and processes best support major incident managers?

Adopting the right tools is critical to overcoming major incident management challenges. Modern platforms can provide the visibility, collaboration, and automation needed to streamline the response effort. Key tools and processes include:

  • Automated Runbooks: Digital, repeatable plans that guide teams through the resolution process step-by-step.
  • Collaboration tools: Centralized communication hubs (like Slack or Microsoft Teams) that are integrated into the response workflow.
  • Real-time monitoring and alerting: Systems that proactively detect issues and automatically trigger the incident response process.
  • Post-incident review procedures: Structured processes for analyzing what went wrong and identifying opportunities for improvement. The role of AI is also becoming crucial, as explained in our article on how AI agents are changing incident manager roles and responsibilities.

How do Cutover’s automated runbooks support major incident managers?

This is where a solution like Cutover Respond becomes a game-changer. The automated runbooks software enables organizations to codify their best-practice response plans into dynamic, executable workflows.

During a critical incident, Cutover's automated runbooks guide teams through every step of the process, from initial triage to final resolution. This dramatically reduces the reliance on manual processes and human memory, minimizing the risk of errors. For major incident managers, this means they can focus on strategic decision-making instead of getting bogged down in the tactical details. 

The platform provides real-time visibility into who is doing what and when, eliminating communication gaps and ensuring everyone is working from the same plan. By automating the process, Cutover eases the pressure on managers, accelerates response times, and ultimately helps protect the business from the damaging impact of major incidents.

Ready to see how you can overcome your major incident management challenges? Learn more about Cutover's approach to automated incident response.

Kimberly Sack
Major incident management
Latest blog posts
How to overcome the top major incident management challenges in your organization
Major IT incidents can cause chaos and downtime. The Major Incident Manager's crucial role is to maintain calm and guide recovery, but they face relentless challenges like communication breakdowns, lack of real-time visibility, and siloed teams. A poor response leads to significant financial loss and reputational damage. This post details the biggest obstacles and provides actionable solutions, including establishing clear authority, standardizing processes, and investing in training. Crucially, it highlights how modern tools like automated runbooks and centralized collaboration platforms—specifically Cutover Respond—can automate workflows, provide real-time visibility, and empower the Major Incident Manager to accelerate resolution and protect the business.
https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/628d0599d1e97aea36c8a467/6917219503b891e411ab4725_blog-challenges-Incident-managers-face.webp
Nov 14, 2025
Nov 14, 2025
Person
Kimberly Sack